Proposed Fiscal Anchor Threatens South Africa’s Constitutional Rights Amid Health Crisis
As Gauteng loses 100 nurses monthly and public health facilities face worsening shortages, proposals to legally bind South Africa to a fiscal anchor are drawing sharp criticism. Experts argue that such measures threaten to entrench austerity, directly undermining constitutional rights by restricting spending on essential social services.
Gauteng province is losing approximately 100 nurses every month, a statistic that underscores the deepening crisis in public healthcare as South Africa considers legally binding fiscal anchors. While the Minister of Finance announced in February that R21.3 billion and R9.9 billion were added to health and education budgets over the medium term—increases pitched deliberately above Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation to defend frontline posts—a recent report reveals that critical positions remain vulnerable to Treasury’s debt-reduction strategies.
The proposed fiscal anchor, which would cap state borrowing and spending within a specific range by establishing a binding debt or primary budget surplus target, has drawn criticism for potentially writing austerity into law. Critics argue that this approach forces public spending, including health worker salaries, to compete for an increasingly tight budget, thereby threatening the stability of frontline services.
The Human Resources for Health (HRH) Strategy projects that South Africa will face a shortage of approximately 97,000 healthcare workers across all categories by 2030. The HRH warns that this shortfall will worsen if health workforce expenditure increases only in line with inflation, a constraint that becomes more acute with the introduction of a legal fiscal anchor. The strategy aims to address inequities across provinces, but current trends suggest that population growth alone will outpace available resources without significant intervention.
Efforts to reduce the public sector wage bill have included offering early retirement packages to civil servants. The stated objective is to replace older, more expensive workers with younger staff; however, data indicates that these positions are often not refilled. Aliya Chikte, a researcher at the Alternative Information and Development Centre (AIDC) and Deputy Chairperson of the Budget Justice Coalition (BJC), notes that voluntary packages tend to attract experienced nurses, doctors, teachers, and specialists—workers the state can least afford to lose. Consequently, the strategy reflects a headcount-reduction exercise rather than generational renewal.
The nursing crisis in Gauteng is part of a broader public sector contraction. According to Gauteng’s Estimates of Provincial Revenue and Expenditure (EPRE), the province reduced its medical and related personnel by 2,899 between the 2024/25 and 2025/26 financial years. An analysis of budget data further shows that the majority of provinces have fewer nurses than they did three years ago.
This reduction in workforce coincides with Treasury’s assertion that the country has maintained a primary budget surplus for three consecutive years. A primary budget surplus occurs when government revenue exceeds expenditure on all items except interest payments on loans. Duncan Pieterse, the Director-General of Treasury, highlighted this trend, yet critics point out that the growing surplus has occurred alongside severe worker shortages in schools, hospitals, and clinics.
The Minister of Health previously indicated in a parliamentary reply that South Africa has only four doctors for every 10,000 people, less than half of the desired international benchmark of 10. Chikte argues that when the Minister describes budget increases as "lifelines," it merely signifies that departments are drowning at a slower pace rather than recovering.
The debate over fiscal policy extends to the reliability of debt metrics. The Minister of Finance has admitted that austerity can be self-defeating and acknowledged Treasury’s position that debt as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is an unreliable indicator because it depends heavily on the GDP denominator. During economic shocks, when GDP falls, the debt-to-GDP ratio can worsen even if the primary budget surplus grows.
With economic growth stagnating and population needs increasing, there are concerns that a binding fiscal anchor will be incompatible with improved socioeconomic outcomes. Parliament’s Standing Committee on Finance recommended in its March 2024 report to National Treasury that "the binding fiscal anchor should not be the trajectory of fiscal policy in relation to public expenditure as they limit fiscal policy parameters and narrow the NT’s fiscal policy orientation."
Chikte emphasizes that the focus should shift to why South Africa pays high interest on its debt and how to ensure debt-service costs do not compete exorbitantly with social and economic development spending. Debt-service costs as a percentage of expenditure are projected to rise from 15% in 2022/23 to 18% in 2028/29.
Research by AIDC, including the South African Fair Tax Monitor and studies on the Government Employees Pension Fund (GEPF), suggests that progressive funding mechanisms remain available. These resources could help stop the erosion of constitutional rights and reduce the cost of servicing debt without shrinking the state. Chikte warns that South Africa, described as the world’s most unequal country, cannot afford to shrink its public sector further.
The context for these fiscal debates includes recent monetary policy adjustments. At last year’s Medium Term Budget Policy Statement (MTBPS), the inflation target was lowered. However, subsequent events, including the war between the US and Israel on Iran and the Reserve Bank’s response, demonstrated the limitations of tighter targets against inflation driven by external shocks. As this year’s MTBPS approaches, critics urge policymakers to avoid locking in reforms that could squeeze an already struggling economy.
M.Schub--FFMTZ